Sour Watermelon Candy Taste Test: Our Honest Review of the Best Sour Sweets

Sour watermelon candy has become a cult favorite among sweet lovers. The combination of a sharp, tangy kick followed by a sweet, fruity finish is irresistible. But with so many options on the market, which ones actually deliver on flavor and texture? We decided to conduct a thorough taste test and review to find out.

Our team gathered a selection of the most talked-about sour watermelon sweets, from classic chews to modern twists. We rated each one on sourness intensity, sweetness balance, chewiness, and overall enjoyment. Here’s what we discovered.

What Makes a Great Sour Watermelon Candy?

The perfect sour watermelon candy should hit you with an immediate burst of tartness that makes your lips pucker, then mellow into a juicy, sweet watermelon flavor. The texture matters too—whether you prefer a soft chew or a firmer bite, the candy should feel satisfying in your mouth. We also looked for a coating of sour sugar or powder that adds an extra layer of tang.

Many brands try to achieve this balance, but few get it exactly right. Some are too sweet, masking the sourness, while others are so aggressively tart that the fruit flavor gets lost. Our taste test aimed to find the candies that nail that perfect harmony.

• Look for a bright, artificial watermelon flavor that tastes like summer.
• The sour coating should be visible and generous, not just a light dusting.
• Chewiness should be soft but not sticky—easy to eat without getting stuck to your teeth.

Our Top Picks from the Taste Test

After sampling multiple products, a few stood out from the crowd. One of our favorites was the Wild Strawberry 54g x 12, which, despite its name, offers a surprisingly bright watermelon-like tang with a soft, chewy texture. The sour coating is perfectly balanced, making it a great choice for anyone who wants a gentle but noticeable sour kick.

Another standout was the Treets Pretzel Bites. While not a traditional watermelon candy, their sweet and salty crunch offers a unique twist that complements sour flavors beautifully. For a classic sour watermelon experience, we also loved the Treets Big Box, which delivers a satisfyingly tart and fruity punch in every bite.

• Wild Strawberry 54g x 12: Best for a balanced sour-sweet watermelon flavor.
• Treets Pretzel Bites: A surprising but delicious alternative with a crunchy texture.
• Treets Big Box: Perfect for sharing and delivering consistent sourness.

Sourness Levels and Flavor Profiles

We rated each candy on a scale of 1 to 10 for sourness. The Treets Big Box scored a solid 7 for its sharp, mouth-puckering initial hit, followed by a sweet watermelon finish that lingers pleasantly. The Wild Strawberry 54g x 12 earned a 6—still tangy but more approachable for those who prefer a milder sour experience. Meanwhile, the Treets Pretzel Bites surprised us with a 5, as the saltiness actually enhances the perception of sourness.

Flavor-wise, the watermelon notes were most authentic in the Wild Strawberry 54g x 12, which uses a natural-tasting fruit profile. The Treets Big Box leans more toward a candy-like watermelon flavor, reminiscent of classic gummy rings. All three were well-received by our panel, but personal preference will dictate which one you reach for.

• Sourness scale: Treets Big Box (7/10), Wild Strawberry 54g x 12 (6/10), Treets Pretzel Bites (5/10).
• Flavor authenticity: Wild Strawberry 54g x 12 leads with a more natural taste.
• Overall enjoyment: Treets Big Box won for its addictive sour-sweet balance.

Texture and Chewiness Comparison

Texture is a critical factor in any candy review. The Treets Big Box features a classic chewy gummy texture that is soft without being overly sticky. It holds its shape well and doesn't get stuck in your teeth. The Wild Strawberry 54g x 12 offers a slightly softer, more delicate chew that melts away quickly, making it easy to eat by the handful.

The Treets Pretzel Bites are in a league of their own—crunchy and salty on the outside, with a creamy center that adds a whole new dimension. While not a gummy, they provide a satisfying contrast that many testers appreciated as a palate cleanser between sour sweets.

• Treets Big Box: Firm but yielding chew, great for slow savoring.
• Wild Strawberry 54g x 12: Soft and quick to dissolve, ideal for snacking.
• Treets Pretzel Bites: Crunchy exterior with a smooth, creamy interior.

Final Ratings and Verdict

After tallying scores from our panel, the Treets Big Box came out on top with an average rating of 8.5/10, praised for its perfect sour-sweet balance and classic gummy texture. The Wild Strawberry 54g x 12 earned an 8/10 for its authentic flavor and soft chew, while the Treets Pretzel Bites scored 7.5/10 for its innovative crunch and saltiness that complements sour flavors.

If you are looking for a pure sour watermelon experience, the Treets Big Box is your best bet. For a milder, more fruit-forward option, go with the Wild Strawberry 54g x 12. And if you want to mix things up, the Treets Pretzel Bites offer a delightful surprise.

• Treets Big Box: 8.5/10—best overall sour watermelon candy.
• Wild Strawberry 54g x 12: 8/10—most authentic watermelon flavor.
• Treets Pretzel Bites: 7.5/10—most creative texture combination.

Whether you crave an intense sour punch or a gentle tangy sweetness, our taste test proves there is a sour watermelon candy out there for you. We highly recommend starting your journey with the Treets Big Box for a classic, crowd-pleasing experience that never disappoints. Explore our full range today and find your new favorite sour treat.